\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://web1.writing.com/main/forums/message_id/3731979
\"Reading Printer Friendly Page Tell A Friend
No ratings.
Rated: 13+ · Message Forum · Contest · #2339870

Short Story Contest

<< Previous  •  Message List  •  Next >>
Reply  •  Post New
May 9, 2025 at 8:49pm
#3731979
Re: Kevin, Cancer, and the Purple Potato
E,

You need to make this a static item so it can get the reviews it deserves. Holy mackerel!

I am almost speechless. Or... Letterless?

Cancer eats a hell of a lot more than one person. It eats entire families, and it vomits out grief in great clouds of static.

I get the impression Kevin and the speaker were boyhood friends, sharing risk and joy alike: "...the boy who’d stolen a tractor joyride at 16, who’d convinced me purple was just blue grieving red." The thought of purple actually being another color feeling an emotion for yet a third—it's hard to even put it into concrete language; it's so wonderfully abstract and poetic that one cannot put his finger on why it is so perfect. And these boys would have done everything together, including learning and enjoying to smoke. The scars on the speaker's chest and Kevin's implied demise link them both through horrible lung cancers—as if "the diagnosis} wasn't enough.

I was impressed by the use of the "baked" potato—an immobile man in hospice, "baked" by radiation, a "vegetable..." These two men share a wry, dark sense of humor, demonstrated with the birthday card and dandelion seeds, and the potato is both a very clever demonstration of their companionship and a surreptitious nod to the reader.

I sense the speaker in this story moving toward his own end, toward a new beginning with Kevin. This plant is not a creeper or a parasite; it's a guide. The tendrils of purple grief are surrounding the speaker in security and familiarity. Nurses can no longer help the cancer that remains in the speaker, even after an apparent lobectomy. The only surcease left is the embrace of an old friend.

Your ability to find just the right phrases holds as strong as ever:

~ The everyday-ness of these lines are anchors the reader can hang onto. "Yeah, that's how my smartass buddy talks. I get this. This is real." Could the writer want anything more from the reader?

        ...a crayon—periwinkle, the label said... “You were right,” he said. “It is a bullshit color.”

        ...dandelion seeds...“Plant these,” he’d written. “They’re assholes. They’ll outlive us all.”

~ "a town I’d buried a decade ago." I originally read this and was excited (talk about dark!) that there might be another Land to be explored. But as I thought about it, I recognized that the town referred to was a survivor guilt that had been accommodated long ago: the loss of Kevin and the speaker's own subsequent survival.


My mother passed from COPD and complications thereof in 2009. She passed peacefully, in hospice. I was there, watching as she let her last breath go. (An aside: why do we always speak of someone "taking their last breath?" Is it because we are projecting our own desire for them to cling to life, to take and hoard every last vestige of existence in our own plane? Why not say "letting out their last breath?" They are moving on; we would do them a service by wishing them a safe journey as their energies are released outward toward the next whatever. Okay, I'm done. You may now resume reading this review.) My wife being lucky/cursed enough to be sensitive enough to see such things, my grandmother (dead since the early nineties) was appearing in my wife's dreams, ready to guide Mom forward. The dream of Kevin beneath his own wry avatar of the potato plant was incredibly moving to me. Death hurts sometimes, and I reckon it can be painful. But it can be beautiful in some ways, too.

Well, now I'm on the subject of avatars, icons, and symbols...

~ The telephone. The ubiquitous telephone. Nurses left voicemails; the vines drank those too. In this context, the speaker is withdrawing into himself getting ready for his own outward journey. The nurses trying to talk to him in his hospice bed no longer reach him; he is busy with more important things. He doesn't even try to keep their words in mind, because he knows they no longer have anything that will help.

~ Resin. I'm rather glad to see this one, although it goes by the name of "oil" here. Oil, resin, viscous phlegm filling the lungs. This having been such a prevalent icon in Relic, I feel validated that some of my interpretations of the symbology of that story were accurate.

~ Vines. The vines of orchids bind and clutch, as in Noctuary; these vines caress and protect. I'll admit, I think I'm a little late to the party in realizing that vines represent the reach of emotions post mortem. Again, the tying together of other stories is giddily exciting for artsy-fartsy old farts like me! *Wink**Laugh*

~ Mother. Her sachet, the somehow uncomfortable perspective of her believe in omens and such. She may not be as direct an agent in this stories as she is in others, but there is a tinge of darkness to her. One must wonder if it was Mother's cigarettes the boys began smoking in the first place.

~ Dandelion seeds. This is such a complex and touching metaphor. They are inconvenient, a weed—much as the sick and dying often seem to those who are well. And the seeds themselves are dead, the color gone from the flower. But a slight wind will carry them away—a beautifully subtle reference to the frailty of cancer patients, many of whom look like a stiff wind really will blow them over. Let the wind blow; these seeds will make new lives just as the seeds of these men may likely have grown the new lives of children or grandchildren themselves. Yes, it is true that they will outlive us, these flowers from our own seeds. And yet, you slip the jab one last time, revealing some lingering bitterness that even the most sanguine of terminal patients must feel toward the active, vital, living individuals around them: "They're assholes."


This short story was not only evocative and touching, my friend. It was also written quite well. The pacing and flow is smooth and slow, as the subject matter would suggest. The memories fit evenly against the edges of the "action," allowing different scenes to occur without demanding that the reader change mental gears. Your economy of words must be noted, as well. You layer metaphors upon other metaphors and wring as many meanings out of a word or phrase as possible. You say what needs to be said, and you leave us enough tools to open up the metaphorical riddle and unpack all the incredible poetically psychological goodies inside. I've also noted in the past that I'll point out warts as well as beauty marks. This time, my gifted friend, I see not a single wart in evidence.

I am gratified by this story, and I continue to look forward to more of your writing. So... (here it comes...wait for it........) write on!

--Jeffrey


PS: By the way, top marks for being an overachiever and including a different title in this story—perfectly within the rules. *Wink*
PPS: No gift points yet until you win or come in second. *Devilish*
MESSAGE THREAD
Kevin, Cancer, and the Purple Potato · 05-09-25 1:06pm
by Enthusiasm Author IconMail Icon
Re: Kevin, Cancer, and the Purple Potato · 05-09-25 1:42pm
by Samantha Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Kevin, Cancer, and the Purple Potato · 05-09-25 2:52pm
by Enthusiasm Author IconMail Icon
*Star* Re: Kevin, Cancer, and the Purple Potato · 05-09-25 8:49pm
by Jeffrey Meyer Author IconMail Icon

<< Previous  •  Message List  •  Next >>
Reply  •  Post New
The following applies to this forum item as a whole, not this post. Feedback sent here will go to the forum's owner, Jeffrey Meyer.
Printed from https://web1.writing.com/main/forums/message_id/3731979