This week: Twists, Turns, and Red Herrings Edited by: Lonewolf  
More Newsletters By This Editor 
 
1. About this Newsletter
2. A Word from our Sponsor
3. Letter from the Editor
4. Editor's Picks
5. A Word from Writing.Com
6. Ask & Answer
7. Removal instructions
| Mystery stories are among the most captivating forms of fiction, but writing one that keeps readers on the edge of their seats requires careful craft. This newsletter explores the essential elements of creating a mystery that surprises without cheating and intrigues without frustrating. |
Mystery stories have a timeless pull, they invite readers to step into the unknown, to sift through clues, and to test their wits against the writer. But writing a mystery that truly keeps readers guessing isn’t easy. Too many red herrings, and readers feel tricked. Too few, and the ending becomes predictable. So how do you strike the right balance?
Here are some core strategies to craft a mystery that captivates until the final reveal.
1. Start With the Puzzle, Not the Pieces
Before you scatter clues across your story, define the solution. Who committed the crime (or what really happened), why, and how? Once you know the endgame, you can work backward to plant foreshadowing and misdirection in the right places.
Think of it as building a maze: the twists and turns feel organic to the reader because you designed them with the exit in mind.
2. Build Compelling Characters With Secrets
The best mysteries don’t just rely on the “whodunit” they thrive on why. Give each suspect motivations, fears, and secrets. Maybe the butler wasn’t the murderer, but he was stealing family heirlooms. Perhaps the best friend wasn’t guilty of the crime, but she was hiding an affair.
Every secret adds a layer of intrigue and keeps readers invested.
3. Scatter Clues, But Don’t Shout Them
Clues should exist in plain sight, but often disguised as background details. A photograph on the mantle. A character’s offhand comment. A missing button.
The trick is to make clues feel ordinary until the reader looks back after the reveal and thinks: Of course, that was there the whole time!
4. Use Red Herrings Wisely
A red herring shouldn’t be a cheap trick, it should make sense in the world of the story. Misdirection works best when it arises from character behavior: someone lies for a reason unrelated to the crime, or acts suspiciously out of fear of exposure.
That way, when the truth emerges, the misdirection still feels believable, not manipulative.
5. Control the Flow of Information
Pacing is everything in mystery writing. Reveal too much too soon, and you spoil the suspense. Hold back too much, and readers get frustrated.
A good rhythm alternates between tension and relief: a small discovery, a dead end, a shocking twist, and then a breakthrough. This “push and pull” keeps readers hooked.
6. Make the Detective Fallible
Whether your sleuth is a professional detective, a curious neighbor, or an amateur blogger, they should make mistakes. Wrong theories and dead ends not only feel realistic, but they also mirror the reader’s own process of guessing, and guessing wrong.
7. Deliver a Satisfying Payoff
The ending is where you cash in all your setup. A great reveal should feel both surprising and inevitable. Readers should gasp at the twist, then nod when they realize all the clues were there.
Avoid the dreaded Deus ex Machina (introducing a new character or fact at the last second). A mystery’s solution must grow naturally from the groundwork you’ve already laid.
 Writing Exercise: The Three Clue Rule
Try writing a short mystery story where the solution can be guessed from exactly three clues. Place one obvious clue, one subtle one, and one misleading clue. See if your test reader catches the truth before the reveal.
 Final Thoughts
A mystery is more than just a puzzle, it’s a story about people under pressure, secrets dragged into the light, and the thrill of discovery. If you can balance fairness with surprise, you’ll create the kind of mystery that keeps readers turning pages deep into the night. |
| |  | Invalid Item
This item number is not valid.
#2345712 by Not Available. |
|
Have an opinion on what you've read here today? Then send the Editor feedback! Find an item that you think would be perfect for showcasing here? Submit it for consideration in the newsletter!
https://www.Writing.Com/go/nl_form
To stop receiving this newsletter, click here for your newsletter subscription list. Simply uncheck the box next to any newsletter(s) you wish to cancel and then click to "Submit Changes". You can edit your subscriptions at any time.
|
Mystery: September 24, 2025 Issue [#13360]
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
Community Newsfeed
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
