Hi
This chapter, "Glitch - Chapter 1: Numb," is a powerful and emotionally charged opening that effectively establishes the protagonist, Luka Swann, and the central conflicts he faces.
Here is a detailed review covering the overall impression and specific areas for improvement:
đ Overall Impression
The chapter is a strong, compelling start to a narrative focused on emotional trauma, family dysfunction, and the struggle for identity. The first-person perspective immediately immerses the reader in Luka's pain, anger, and deep-seated loneliness.
The author does an excellent job of portraying Luka's internal landscape. His coping mechanismsâsarcasm, aggressive deflection, and escaping into codeâfeel authentic to a teenager grappling with loss (his father's death) and emotional abuse (from his mother and sister, Sofie). The voice is raw, intense, and captivating, making Luka a flawed yet sympathetic character despite his mean-spirited actions toward others.
The introduction of Nightshade at the end creates a great hook for the next chapter, promising a shift in the nature of Luka's emotional retreat and hinting at a potential thriller or mystery element.
âď¸ Tips for Improvement
1. đ˘ Pacing and Dialogue Realism
While the chapter is gripping, the rapid-fire, highly theatrical dialogue, especially the exchanges with the other students and Sofie, sometimes feels less like natural conversation and more like a series of meticulously crafted insults.
* Luka's interactions with peers: The students react to Luka's cruelty ("You do know that only idiots would blush at girls like you, donât you?") and then instantly pivot to the "Fight! Fight!" chant with an almost cartoonish speed. This might benefit from a beat of more realistic shock or social withdrawal from the crowd before the taunting begins.
* Sofie's Character: Sofie is written almost purely as an antagonist, a gloating villain. To make the sibling rivalry feel more complex and the pain of Luka's family life more visceral, consider giving Sofie a moment of subtle vulnerability or a less polished insult that hints at her own pressure or insecurity. The current dialogue ("Who would want to talk to you, Luka? You know, other than to ask how to stop being drunk?") is a little too clean and cutting, making her sound like a professional tormentor rather than a competitive sister.
2. đşď¸ Setting and Show-Not-Tell
The emotional landscape is vivid, but the physical environment of Evergreen Academy and the Swann home could use more detailed grounding to enhance the contrast between Luka's internal chaos and the external setting.
* "Show, Don't Tell" with Mother: The mother's emotional neglect is stated repeatedly ("scold me for 'leaking emotion,'" "Motherâs watching me like a hawk," "screaming at me to leave her alone"). While the dialogue scene where she ignores him and barks "SHUT UP!" is fantastic, the earlier sections could be tightened to show her coldness through actions rather than simply stating her lack of love.
* The School Scene: The morning passes in a "blur," which is fine, but the teacher's lesson is described with abstract "blah, blah" language. Grounding this briefly with an actual subject (e.g., a complex history equation or a piece of literature) would make the ensuing classroom drama feel more real and make Luka's defiance seem more targeted.
3. đ§ Emotional Arc and Repetition
Luka's self-hatred and fear of weakness are the core of the chapter, but the internal monologue circles back to the same themesâloneliness, Mother's disapproval, Sofie's perfection, and his father's deathâmany times.
* Refine the Monologue: Consider combining some of the internal thoughts to maintain the emotional intensity without making it feel repetitive. For example, instead of running through the whole list of his pain points again after the Nora scene, perhaps focus just on the shame Nora made him feel and how that triggers his established coping mechanism.
* The Nora Scene: This interaction is key, as it's the first time he attempts an actual connection and fails, triggering his massive emotional crash. The moment when Nora shows him the drawing of the potato is brilliantly humiliating and serves as a perfect catalyst for his spiral into tears.
4. đť The Hacking Scene
The introduction of Luka's hacking talent is a great way to showcase his intellect and provide a unique coping mechanism.
* Clarity on "Hacking": The internal terminology ("reasonable code changes," "backdoor that erases my whole search history") is a little vague. To solidify his identity as a clever coder, you could offer one concrete detail about the shortcut or the parent filter's "lazy code," which would make his technical abilities feel more impressive.
Focusing on both aspects is a great idea, as Luka's internal conflict is the reason for his vulnerability, and Nightshade is the catalyst exploiting that vulnerability.
1. đ Luka's Internal Conflict: The Psychology of "Numb"
Luka's conflict is rooted in profound grief and chronic emotional neglect, which he attempts to manage through rigid, unhealthy defense mechanisms.
đ Defense Mechanisms and Masking
Luka's primary conflict is the desperate need to keep his emotions "bottled up" to survive in his hostile environment, primarily governed by his mother's rule that weakness is a "disgrace."
* Aggressive Sarcasm/Bullying: His cruelty towards his peers and Sofie is a classic defense mechanism: projection. He projects his own feelings of uselessness and inadequacy onto others to gain a fleeting sense of superiority and control. He says he feels "superior to all people," yet the narrator makes it clear this is a hollow mask.
* Example: Telling the boy, "Go carry your own weight first," after being asked to play soccer.
* Intellectual/Digital Retreat: His self-taught coding and "hacking" are a form of intellectualization and escape. The digital world provides a predictable space where "the internet canât betray you the way people can," giving him a false sense of control and "false calm and love."
* Self-Punishment: He punishes himself physically ("I punch myself hard in the gut" to stay awake) and emotionally ("How stupid of me to cry like that") for being human, reinforcing his mother's critical voice, which has become internalized.
âď¸ The Source of Pain: Grief vs. Neglect
The chapter expertly weaves together two separate traumas:
* Grief (Father's Death): The loss of the one person who understood him. This is the source of the "crashing waves of flashbacks" and the deep, heavy sadness. His father's memory is tied to true, unconditional love.
* Neglect (Mother and Sofie): The source of his anger and jealousy. His mother's contempt and Sofie's competitive success actively reinforce his fear that he is worthless ("If the adoption center were open, Iâd dump you there myself").
The scene where he finally breaks down in the rain is a perfect merging of these two conflicts, showing the collapse of his defenses: The teacher's word "family" triggers the truth, which is immediately followed by Mother's cruel voice ringing in his ears, culminating in him weeping until he has "no more tears left to cry."
2. đť The Nightshade Hook: A Threat or an Opportunity?
The introduction of the hacker, Nightshade, is a brilliant turn that elevates the story beyond a simple character study of grief and bullying.
đ§ Effectiveness of the Confrontation
The scene maximizes tension through several key elements:
* Violation of Privacy: Nightshade doesn't just hack his bank account; they hack his emotions ("A LITTLE BIRDIE TOLD ME THAT YOU ARE LOOKING FOR ROMANCE ADVICE"). This is a profound invasion of the one place Luka thought was safe and under his control (his computer/code).
* The "I SEE YOU" Message: This is a classic thriller device that shatters Luka's carefully constructed isolation. The capital letters, lurid green streak, and immediate freeze/unfreeze action make the threat feel paranormal, not just technological.
* Exploiting Vulnerability: Nightshade immediately targets Luka's two greatest shames: his secret desire for "romantic advice" (a vulnerable, "weak" emotion) and his internal loneliness ("I AM NO SCAMMER" after he wonders how he can "scam the scammer"). Nightshade immediately demonstrates a level of insight that mirrors Luka's own intrusive, self-hating thoughts.
đŽ Potential Plot Directions
Nightshade presents the most intriguing direction for the narrative:
| Plot Direction | Implication |
|---|---|
| The Ally/Mentor | Nightshade is a troubled genius who sees Luka's pain and skill, offering him a path out through technology, potentially leading him to use his coding for illegal or vigilante purposes (a common theme in "hacker" narratives). |
| The Antagonist/Stalker | Nightshade is directly connected to the family, perhaps even working for the mother or Sofie, or is a highly intelligent, manipulative classmate (like Nora or Beatrice), using this access to control and torment him further. |
| The Internal Manifestation | Nightshade is a sophisticated extension of Luka's trauma, a code-based embodiment of his self-critical thoughts and desire for connection/destruction. This would deepen the psychological thriller aspect. |
The final question, "Who is this 'Nightshade' that was just talking to me? It seems she knows a lot more than me than she will let on, assuming it's a girl," shows Luka is already intrigued despite his fear, setting up a clear motivation for the next chapter. He is willing to risk everything, even getting caught by Mother, for the chance to engage with someone who genuinely sees him, even if that person is a dangerous stalker.
đŻ Specific Compliments
* The Opening Paragraph: The imageryâ"tingling numbness," "heartbeat tossing back and forth like a boat in a storm"âis excellent and immediately sets a tone of anxiety and emotional suppression.
* Nora's Potato Drawing: This is the single strongest moment of the chapter. It's unexpected, funny, and devastatingly effective at breaking down Luka's self-aggrandizing facade.
* Nightshade's Introduction: The final scene is highly effective. The capital letters, the lurking, the use of his search history, and the chilling final line "I SEE YOU" transform the story from a character study into a promising mystery/thriller.
Keep up the great work! The chapter is captivating, and Luka's voice is unforgettable. The foundation for an excellent story is set...sindbad
|
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
Community Newsfeed
Puzzle Hub
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
My review has been submitted for consideration in "